4chan archive /mlp/ (index)
similar threads
2013-05-10 01:24 10455878 Anonymous (46bca804-f132-48e6-8df1-88edde9fa694.jpg 714x960 46kB)
This makes no sense.
they use a Soviet styled propaganda poster.
Yet they portray a message of hate and inequality.
I hate the uneducated
3 min later 10455990 Anonymous
>>10455878
This is still a thing?
6 min later 10456042 Anonymous
>>10455990
For as long as edgy 13-year-olds exist, this will be a thing.
6 min later 10456055 Anonymous
Silly OP, communism is about hatred.
7 min later 10456076 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10455990
It's a really small thing, but yes it still exists. A funny is that they say they don't hate mlp, just the fanbase.
7 min later 10456079 Anonymous
>>10456042
but anon if we don't have edgy kid then they will all be brony and that mean lot's of spaghetti
do you want to swim in their spaghetti
9 min later 10456102 Anonymous (1351224888861.png 1024x768 99kB)
>>10456055
>Not being Pro-Communism
>2013
10 min later 10456136 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10456055
>>10456102
Are we going into /pol/ mode? Cause i wouldn't mind a good banter.
10 min later 10456142 Anonymous
>>10456055
Ok anon. Ok.
11 min later 10456151 Anonymous (bronies..jpg 486x324 137kB)
>>10455878
Why the hell would you be anti-brownie? Brownies are delicious and loved by people of all ages from around the world.
11 min later 10456155 Anonymous (1353187999957_2.jpg 786x1017 98kB)
>>10455878
fixed
12 min later 10456188 Anonymous (1234.jpg 1069x747 141kB)
14 min later 10456224 Anonymous
>>10456102
I can understand the appeal of a Communist society but it just doesn't work. Before the Soviet Union even collapsed, "Communism" had been taken over by a few paranoid, power-hungry individuals, namely Stalin. The same goes for every other Communist state. The people were betrayed.
15 min later 10456251 Mau
>>10455878
This bring me memories
There's a bunch of fags in Taringa who made that stuff a few months..
Was really fun indeed
16 min later 10456266 Anonymous
>>10456102
>"people work for stuff! therefore, all the stuff they work for should belong to me!"
On a more serious note, communism is completely unsustainable, since effective communism relies on people denying human nature and self-interest. It's a pretty thought, but it will probably never happen.
16 min later 10456271 Anonymous (1366239437180.jpg 446x600 76kB)
>>10456224
stalin did nothing wrong
16 min later 10456281 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10456224
What about a democratic communism? Though that probably is a pipe dream at best right now.
17 min later 10456300 BPR
>>10456188
Bad pic. Delete from folder.
17 min later 10456316 Anonymous
>>10456055
To my original point, OP was being a hypocrite in denying that Communism is about hatred. It's an ideology build on hatred of the upper classes.
18 min later 10456324 Anonymous
>>10456224
I agree with you. I guess all I can say is it needs some type of positive innovation.
18 min later 10456333 Anonymous
>>10456271
ioseb besarionis je juḡašvili pls
19 min later 10456353 Anonymous (1366489747413.jpg 468x700 87kB)
>>10456300
nope
i never thinked about it but adding Derpy on the pic made me realise what an brave and great person Che was in an artistic expression
20 min later 10456373 Anonymous
>>10456281
Democratic Communism would require mob rule. History has shown that a majority of individuals in Communist states were apathetic as best towards the cause. Even then we're not taking individual's greed and ambition into the equation.
21 min later 10456390 Anonymous (MUH60MILLION.png 800x2449 942kB)
>>10456333
Seriously.
21 min later 10456401 Anonymous
>>10456373
>*at best
>*the individual's
23 min later 10456431 Anonymous
>>10456281
Why not anarco-communism?
24 min later 10456463 Anonymous
>>10456390
also
>1945
>America was never bombed or invaded and has 300,000 dead from the war
>The USSR was the primary target of the German war machine and was the site of the largest land war in history. They also had 16,000,000 dead from the war
>The US was experiencing a post-war boom while Russia's infrastructure was totally destroyed
>Fear of nonexistent Russian aggression caused the Americans to begin a massive buildup of troops and nuclear weapons
>The Russians have no choice to respond to the aggression of the West so they begin to build troops and are forced to spend precious resources on the military rather than desperately needed infrastructure
>the US has a long list of what amount to slave labour camps governed by puppet dictators while Russia's relationships with their "allies" and "puppet states" in Eastern Europe are shaky at best
>The US receives massive amounts of wealth from the invasion of multiple countries which boosts their economy which has come to rely on military production to function properly
>Russia invades two countries throughout the entire Cold War, Hungary and Afghanistan. In both cases the Russians are asked to intervene by the local governments
With conditions like this the mere fact that they competed with the US for over fourty years is a testament to Communism. Besides there was nothing bad in the Soviet Union that doesn't also happen in the US
25 min later 10456485 Anonymous (image.jpg 555x569 97kB)
>>10456431
Like
>>10456373
but a hell of a lot worse.
25 min later 10456494 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10456373
yeah, mod rule wouldn't work, and true communism is impossible as there needs to be some gradient of power else Anarchy will break. the closest we'll ever get to a 'just' communism is a democratic socialist republic.
26 min later 10456499 Anonymous
>>10456431
>not council communism
BOURGEOIS SWINE
27 min later 10456535 Anonymous
>>10456390
Harward also had to admits that Mao ''genocide'' were overstated on death numbers.
27 min later 10456561 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10456431
I just realized that an anarchist communist state is impossible to due as the two ideologies are at ends with each other on certain issues.
28 min later 10456578 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10456535
I wouldn't call the great leap forward a genocide as much as a massive fuck up.
28 min later 10456582 Anonymous (death-chart-of-growth-mao.jpg 491x581 53kB)
>>10456535
30 min later 10456607 Anonymous (135588311487.jpg 960x720 65kB)
31 min later 10456641 Anonymous (image.jpg 1280x600 201kB)
>>10456494
>mod rule won't work
>mod rule
>mod
Come my brothers! Today we overthrow the mods and usher in a bright new future!
33 min later 10456665 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10456641
Did I just accidentally propagate cyber communism?
33 min later 10456681 Anonymous (its happening.gif 320x213 616kB)
>>10456665
33 min later 10456687 Anonymous
>>10456102
>2000+13
>being pro communism
>Not being libertarian
34 min later 10456712 Anonymous
>>10456687
visit somalia
35 min later 10456722 Anonymous (image.jpg 960x832 374kB)
>>10456665
The posters have nothing to lose but their chains. We have a board to win
>Anons of the world, UNITE!
35 min later 10456742 Anonymous
>>10456578
Actually the leap was a success, deaths were fabricated and the numbers of deaths in "Genocides" are astoundingly inaccurate.
See >>10456582
36 min later 10456757 Anonymous (004.png 329x312 120kB)
Politics are so dumb.
36 min later 10456772 Anonymous
>>10456722
DEATH TO THE BOURGEOIS TRIPFAG MENACE
36 min later 10456777 Anonymous
This guy know whats up
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cagh sVNBnQs
38 min later 10456809 Anonymous
>>10456561
How so( and please don't even suggest that such a thing as "anarch"-capitalism even exists)?
38 min later 10456816 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10456742
Oh I know the deaths were grossly exaggerated and it did greatly industrialize a give China the production capability we see today. i'm just saying it makes no sense to call an action with the intent to help the people and with no malicious implications a genocide.
40 min later 10456875 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10456809
Oh no, just politically they just wouldn't mix as communism says that the government should take and distribute the wealth and anarchism says have no government. AKA communism called for a strong centralized government and anarchism calls for none.
41 min later 10456893 Anonymous
>>10456463
>America was never bombed or invaded
Aleutian islands?
Pearl Harbor?
41 min later 10456903 Anonymous (1365869942286.jpg 419x262 62kB)
>>10456757
but not when its communism
42 min later 10456919 Anonymous (121711.png 386x345 128kB)
>>10456875
>communism calls for a strong centralized government
You don't know what communism is do you?
42 min later 10456946 Anonymous
>>10456816
Even if the death tole is exaggerated, doesn't ordain Mao to kill hundreds of thousands of his own countrymen. Mass Murder is still murder and should be treated as such.
44 min later 10456980 Anonymous
>>10456875
lel no
It actually fits quite nicely with each other, the wealth is owned collectively.
44 min later 10456986 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10456919
Like I said, true communism is impossible, and the only form that exists is one with centralization of the government.
44 min later 10456990 Anonymous
>>10456903
I really can't say I care for communism either.
44 min later 10456994 Anonymous (the_butt_of_jokes.jpg 420x312 11kB)
>>10456946
bitch please
46 min later 10457031 Anonymous
>>10456986
>What is Catalonia and Free Territory
47 min later 10457060 Anonymous
>>10456946
You mean the same murder the Nationalists committed on its own people? Mao was simply enacting Justice.
48 min later 10457087 Anonymous (image.jpg 944x531 130kB)
>>10456994
>It's only murder when it's done to humans
Nazi logic
49 min later 10457109 Anonymous
>>10456946
mao had lowered it death rate sharply from 20 per thousand to 12 per thousand between 1953 and 1958. (India did not reach the latter level until over a quarter century later.) After the radical land reforms and the formation of rural cooperatives, there were mass campaigns to clean up the environment and do away with disease bearing pests while a basic rural health care system was put in place. That a dramatic reduction in the rural death rate was achieved, is not disputed by anyone.
49 min later 10457127 Anonymous
>>10456986
Communism is a stateless, classless society with common/worker ownership of the means of production. Communism has never fully existed, but there are several ideas on how to achieve it. One, is Marxist communism, which believes there must be a transitional socialist state before communism can be achieved, while Anarcho-communism believes that there is no need for a transitional state and that they can go straight from capitalism to communism. The states mistakenly known as communist were actually Marxist-Leninist states still in the socialist stage of dialectical materialism. They never reached the communist stage, so they can not be described as communism, so communism can't be said to have failed, only the Marxist-Leninist path.
51 min later 10457162 Anonymous
>>10457060
The nationalists were the only ones actively fighting the Japs enough to make a difference. If it wasn't for the Nationalists, the Commies wouldn't have come to power.
51 min later 10457166 Anonymous
>>10456712
Do you even know what libertarianism is?
SOME goverment not a bunch of niggers runnning around you dumbcunt
51 min later 10457168 Holy Roman Emperor
>>10457031
The problem with that is that they got absorbed by neighboring countries, also Free territory had a life of 3 years, incredibly short for a country.
52 min later 10457206 Anonymous
>>10457162
This justifies the treatment and mass murder of its own citizens?
53 min later 10457233 Anonymous
>>10457127
Or we could just line up all the fucking politicians and shoot them.
54 min later 10457271 Anonymous (statismvsanarchy.jpg 1000x936 295kB)
55 min later 10457317 Anonymous (State.png 960x600 661kB)
>>10457233
u a fukin statist?
56 min later 10457338 Anonymous
>>10457166
what exactly would libertarianism fix? Inflation, workers rights, end war?
somalia is a testament of freemarket capitalism, it may not be run by goverment but it will be run by war lords and whoever gets to the top
58 min later 10457386 Anonymous (17.png 1317x547 122kB)
>>10457317
>tfw someone posts your oc
>>10457271
>anclap detected
59 min later 10457403 Anonymous (NONONONO.gif 158x129 920kB)
>>10457271
Can you feel the bias
59 min later 10457407 Anonymous (Party.png 525x638 43kB)
Yay!
59 min later 10457418 Anonymous
>>10457206
They were fighting a just war against the genocidal Japanese. The communists were subjugating their own people with forced labor and still managed to kill more. The nationalists should not have Clemency for their actions, they should be judged as well, but the harsher sentence should go to those who unjustly murdered more.
1 hours later 10457442 Anonymous (1353602371656.jpg 480x563 144kB)
>>10457386
>voluntarism
i bet the freemarket will have a market on that too
1 hours later 10457459 Anonymous
>>10457418
>Do you even Chinese Civil war?
>Do you even basic history of Contemporary China?
1 hours later 10457469 Anonymous
>>10457442
Did you even read it? It was against voluntarism.
1 hours later 10457470 Anonymous
>>10457271
>THIS IS WHAT ANARCHISM IS
DON'T TELL ME WHAT TO BELIEVE YOU FACIST PIG DOG
1 hours later 10457500 Anonymous (1367799561180.gif 250x250 1016kB)
>>10457338
>Somalia is a testament of freemarket capitalism
>Ignoring the fact that Somalia's previous dictatorship under Siad Barre was a communist regime that bankrupt the country into poverty and instability
read a book m8
1 hours later 10457503 Anonymous (1364958711933.jpg 1000x794 134kB)
>>10457386
>voluntarism
Implying libertarians ever volunteer on anything
1 hours later 10457511 Anonymous
>>10457470
This is simply information, it is up to you to decide whether to accept it.
1 hours later 10457517 Anonymous
>>10457503
See >>10457469
1 hours later 10457550 Anonymous
>>10457338
See Somalia has never been civilized, what makes you think drug lords are going to try to fuck with anyone when nearly everyone has a rifle?
With government they can be SOME control. So they still have a army and a MOSTLY armed populace.
1 hours later 10457585 Anonymous (1366736114351.png 502x345 111kB)
>>10456353
>Tfw he couldn't complete his mission
1 hours later 10457640 Anonymous
>>10457511
I was just trying to make a funny, but really, that infograph is full of bias and tries to make anarchism look like a system of peace. It can be, but like Communism and every other "perfect" system it will fail because it ignores the worst of human nature.
1 hours later 10457668 Anonymous (rothbardchalkboard.jpg 2167x2490 2829kB)
Ancap here.
Ask me anything
1 hours later 10457682 Anonymous (1363985987843.jpg 378x338 51kB)
>>10457585
1 hours later 10457756 Anonymous
>>10457668
Why do you follow such a retarded ideology?
1 hours later 10457785 Anonymous (1364578512830.png 1237x502 200kB)
1 hours later 10457832 Anonymous
>>10457756
Because muh freedom
Also, why does your critique solely consist of name calling?
1 hours later 10457844 Anonymous
>>10457668
how do you really make capitalism stateless without someone capitalising?
1 hours later 10457856 Anonymous
>>10457832
See >>10457386
1 hours later 10457872 Anonymous (1367405120721.gif 498x373 505kB)
>>10457585
excelent
1 hours later 10458138 Anonymous
>>10457844
>capitalising
elaborate
>>10457856
those are all common and reasonable objections, but misleading
A) misunderstanding of the homesteading concept
B) ignorance of history, and the circumstances surrounding the formation of feudal states
C) assumption that all voluntarists follow NAP, though many do, I personally don't
1.327 0.116