4chan archive /lgbt/ (index)
similar threads
2014-10-03 12:20 3380322 Anonymous (1303002236003.jpg 596x576 50kB)
SJW'S FIRE UP THEM TUMBLERS!!! South park is going to have another episode about trannies. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xFT 7Sxvnsww >Cartman puts a little pink bow on his hat and claims he is transsexual, meaning he is a girl. He goes into the little girls bathroom and says "its ok Red, I'm just taking a shit cause I'm a stupid girl like you now." Discuss

2 min later 3380325 Anonymous
South Park is still making new episodes?

3 min later 3380328 Anonymous
>>3380322 >getting in anyway offended by south park >2014

6 min later 3380331 Anonymous
>>3380328 >implying there wont be long ass rants on tumblr about how offended everyone is

6 min later 3380332 StraightWhiteGuy
>>3380322 But that's funny

12 min later 3380341 Anonymous
>>3380332 no wonder mtfg hates you...

15 min later 3380346 StraightWhiteGuy
>>3380341 At least I have you, anon

30 min later 3380369 Anonymous
>>3380322 Why do they think it's appropriate to make these jokes?

59 min later 3380396 Anonymous
>>3380369 >Why do they think it's appropriate to make these jokes? Yeah it's the first time in 20 years that anyone has considered them to be offensive.

1 hours later 3380401 StraightWhiteGuy
>>3380369 Appropriate has nothing to do with it

1 hours later 3380411 Anonymous (14506-1410447796.gif 500x351 1007kB)
>>3380369 its not appropriate, which is why its fucking hilarious

1 hours later 3380412 Anonymous
>>3380369 >appropriate Not everyone cares about that.

1 hours later 3380414 Anonymous
>>3380396 Ofc it wasn't appropriate back then either... But I had hoped the people who make these shows weren't completely retarded, though I guess that's a bit naive.

1 hours later 3380420 Anonymous
They are making fun of anything that's why it's funny. They're not like yeah cause they are trans we won't make fun of them cause they are different... They make fun of jews/black/muslims/white ANYTHING they're just treating trans as if they were like everybody... Isn't what they want?

1 hours later 3380466 Anonymous
>>3380411 >>3380412 >>3380420 If there weren't attempts by law to ban trans women from womens bathroom, and other issues like that, it'd be "appropriate"... But since there's no acceptance for trans people it's not appropriate.

1 hours later 3380475 Anonymous
>>3380466 In comedy, whether things are "appropriate" doesn't matter.

1 hours later 3380476 Anonymous
>>3380466 >why does not everybody agree with my oddly specific morals!??!

1 hours later 3380478 Anonymous
>>3380466 Cry me a river

1 hours later 3380483 Anonymous
>>3380466 I think you'll find it's a parody of transtrenders more than anything else. Those people who claim to be trans but are MAAB and male presenting. A takedown of special snowflakes, if you will. Throw into that gross out toilet humour and you have the scene in the trailer.

1 hours later 3380491 Anonymous
>>3380483 No one in real life really cares about the difference

1 hours later 3380494 Anonymous (retarded-cartman.jpg 205x212 10kB)
>>3380483 i've got the feeling I already know the plot of this episode from somewhere

1 hours later 3380500 Anonymous
>>3380491 No one in real life cares if you're offended.

1 hours later 3380509 Anonymous
The problem with what they did last time was that it was a misrepresentation of transexualality at a time when not many people even knew what it was. This one is touching on a pretty hard subject because some women are even scared to let their daughters go in the restroom because they fear MtFs will be in there to peek on them. When you take a misrepresented subject and then give people a new source of the same misinformation, that's pretty fucked up. Especially if it can lead to someone getting hurt in the future.

1 hours later 3380512 Anonymous
>>3380509 >a new source of the same misinformation How much of an idiot do you have to be to consider south park a new source of information? holy fuck, please stop

2 hours later 3380517 Anonymous
>>3380509 It's not an artist's fault if their art is misinterpreted.

2 hours later 3380521 Anonymous
>>3380475 It does, it's very important in comedy. Comedy is about being funny, not about being offensive. >>3380483 Except nobody knows there's a difference, transtrenders, transvestites and transsexuals are all the same in their mind.

2 hours later 3380524 Anonymous
>>3380512 I'm not saying anyone should take south park seriously, but there are actually a lot of people who can't realize they shouldn't take it seriously. For example, there are quite a few kids and early teens that watch it nowadays.

2 hours later 3380532 Anonymous
>>3380517 You can't misinterpret south park.

2 hours later 3380533 Anonymous
>>3380521 So what you're saying is that until the world's population understands queer theory and smashes the gender binary, nobody can ever satirise the transtrenders? Even though they're a group of people so very clearly deserving of satire?

2 hours later 3380535 Anonymous
>>3380533 They aren't making fun of "xir", but of trans people, because that's how they view trans people, as people who just think they're a woman because they like pink.

2 hours later 3380537 Anonymous
>>3380500 My mom does

2 hours later 3380542 Anonymous
>>3380521 >Comedy is about being funny, not about being offensive Who told you that? I'm sorry, but they lied to you. Comedy is about being funny.

2 hours later 3380545 Anonymous
>>3380542 And sometimes humor offends people. That's nobody's business but theirs.

2 hours later 3380547 Anonymous
>>3380535 We won't know until the episode airs. Some "transgender" people really do think they're women because they like pink. See non-dysphoric trans people.

2 hours later 3380553 Anonymous
>>3380322 >Cartman is an offensive asshole That's pretty much the entire basis of his character, and it's been hilarious all along. He's the incarnation of /pol/ but with the stones to not just be a keyboard warrior.

2 hours later 3380563 Anonymous
>>3380553 But it isn't funny, because people don't know what transsexuals are. Had everyone known what transsexuals were, making this kind of parody would be fine. Now it's more like "lets laugh at these weird people that we don't understand", instead of "gee, that person really don't understand what they're doing, that's not what trans is".

2 hours later 3380564 Anonymous
I can see Mr. Garrison having a big role in this one.

2 hours later 3380570 Anonymous
>>3380563 Listen, this is my first time responding to you, but speaking as a trans person, we literally can't know how this episode will go based on an incredibly short trailer. You'd be better off complaining about the Mr. Garrison episode right now than this one.

2 hours later 3380571 Anonymous
>>3380563 Well, tough. You are allowed to find things unfunny.

2 hours later 3380574 Anonymous
>>3380570 This is south park, I think we know how it's going to turn out. American comedy isn't exactly unpredictable.

2 hours later 3380585 Anonymous (mighty_boosh_blue.jpg 470x470 50kB)
>>3380574 Let's not act like Americans are the only ones producing shit-tier comedy

2 hours later 3380589 Anonymous
>>3380563 except it is funny

2 hours later 3380591 StraightWhiteGuy
>>3380521 >Comedy is about being funny, not about being offensive Since when?

2 hours later 3380592 Anonymous
>>3380563 If people are laughing at weird people they don't understand, they're finding it funny. It's not very nice that they're laughing at them, but it's funny.

2 hours later 3380700 Anonymous
>>3380585 Not really a boosh fan but I wanna bend Noel Fielding over and fuck him raw.

3 hours later 3380743 Anonymous
They've yet to tap into the gold mine of satire. Taking the piss out of everyone's favourite internet users... the SJW themselves.

3 hours later 3380780 Anonymous
>>3380322 Wow you don't even try to hide your communist roots do you.

3 hours later 3380782 Anonymous
>>3380369 They're libertarians. The more they offend people with their retardation, the happier they are, especially as they make money doing that.

3 hours later 3380787 Anonymous
>>3380782 you just described my perfect job

3 hours later 3380803 Anonymous
>>3380787 Have you considered becoming the next spokesthing for the Tea Party?

3 hours later 3380804 Anonymous (500px-Save_Mojo.png 500x273 154kB)
u guiz mite enjoy this www.youtube.com/watch?v=LUdHA5liNec

13 hours later 3383189 Anonymous
Either it's all okay to make fun of, or none of it is.

13 hours later 3383427 Anonymous
>>3380782 >liberals calling libertarians retarded https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e03 hQELqvMo

14 hours later 3383457 Anonymous
>>3380782 >retardation Because it's easier to strawman than it is to think! HILARY CLINTON 2016

14 hours later 3383694 Anonymous (grandpa_simpson_yelling_at_cloud_thumb.jpg 460x346 38kB)
For shit's sake, if Cartman is doing isn't precisely the point that it's fucking retarded? I just played through an entire game where one of the characters LARP'd as a girl and except for Cartman everyone rolled with it.

14 hours later 3383720 Anonymous (1409677654105.jpg 400x386 28kB)
Jesus I love Trey Parker.

14 hours later 3383748 Anonymous
Soup rise soup rise. It's not a big deal, it might get more discussion going about and probably influence negative thought patterns like SP tends to do. Won't be the first time.

15 hours later 3383762 Anonymous
>trannies * About pretendbians and SJW cancer like chris chan who as long as they identify themselves female/lesbian they can intrude the women's bathroom and rape women there.

15 hours later 3383777 Anonymous
>>3380563 Yeah, I agree. But they've done that kind of shit before.

15 hours later 3383798 Anonymous
>STOP LAUGHING AT THINGS I DON'T FIND FUNNY >I DON'T LIKE THIS, CHANGE EVERYTHING >I DEMAND YOU ALL PLAY ALONG WITH MY DELUSIONS ... >WAHHH WHY DOES EVERYONE HATE ME SO MUCH? Trannys, that's you.

15 hours later 3383899 Anonymous
I think it might not be a shitshow if the 'moral' of the episode is that nobody actually fucking does this in real life, and you would have to be a Cartman level sociopath to even consider it to be appropriate behavior. Maybe they learned from Ms. Garrison, maybe they didn't. I'm not holding my breath but it's possible at least.

15 hours later 3383994 Anonymous
Who cares? South Park's whole schtick is being edgy and offensive, and they at least do it better than family guy. It's like being offended by fucking 4chan.

15 hours later 3384081 Anonymous
South park has been pretty bad for years now, they really lost the spark they can make fun of whatever they want though

16 hours later 3384184 Anonymous
>>3383899 was kind of wondering if he was going to be contrasted with a genuinely trans kid who ends up unable to use the bathroom on account of cartman

16 hours later 3384199 Anonymous
>>3384184 I'd like to think they'd pull off something like the tourettes episode with it

16 hours later 3384214 Anonymous
>>3384081 Plebeian who used to like South Park only because of its fecal/edgy humor in early episodes and can't handle more recent intellectual episodes spotted.

17 hours later 3384411 Anonymous (1351235151.png 304x304 148kB)
>>3380322 I don't know why people in this thread are acting like anyone is just a pussy who's offended if they seriously don't like the fact that they're doing. I still haven't heard people shut the fuck up with just spouting off the arguments SP used last time they did an episode making fun of trans people. Like, this shit is actively contributing to making my life worse and can go fuck itself because of that.

2.889 0.111